Connect with us

Let's Talk Hemp

FDA Hearing on CBD Raises More Questions than Answers

Ben Droz

Hemp News

FDA Hearing on CBD Raises More Questions than Answers

By Ben Droz

Last Friday, May 31, the FDA held its first ever, full day public meeting on Cannabis.  7am-6pm, the meeting is part of a Public Comment Period  for “Scientific Data and Information about Products Containing Cannabis or Cannabis-Derived Compounds”

(Docket ID FDA-2019-N-1482)  This docket is accepting comments until July 2nd, and is a very important part of the FDA regulation process.

A panel of 13 Senior FDA officials heard from some 140 people, live from the FDA building in Silver Spring.  The day kicked off with great testimony from hemp lobbyists Jason Amatucci and the Hemp Roundtable’s Jonathan Miller, articulating the position of the hemp industry, that CBD should be viewed as a food ingredient or dietary supplement.  This is already how CBD is being being used.

The conflict comes from the fact that the Pharma drug Epidiolex seems to the FDA to be to similar to plant derived hemp extract, and therefore, does not qualify as a dietary supplement.  While hemp has been a food ingredient since before the enactment of DSHEA in 1994, the FDA seems to think that modern hemp extracts are somehow different because of their processing.  But in fact, it is not different, it is simply a plant derived extract, like any other legal plant derived dietary supplement that you can get at any health food store.  Hemp attorney Rob Kight articulated this point.

But there was also testimony against our causes.  There was testimony that confused and conflated hemp and marijuana.  There was testimony that looked at the complexities of the issue rather than seeing it as simply, let people have CBD.

I personally like to just ignore the haters, and have valid reasons to do so.  Firstly, all of the confusion stems from the mis-interpretation from the FDA of the language in the Farm Bill that specifically protects hemp extracts and cannabinoids.  The FDA is in charge of keeping the public safe, not to restrict natural plant extracts.  All CBD products should meet a baseline of requirements to be in the market, such as C-GMP manufacturing standards, and trackability of supply chain.  Anything more than that should only apply to pharmaceutical grade dosage, which could be in the hundreds and hundreds of milligrams per day.

Importantly, and possibly to reflect the idea that the FDA knows that hemp derived CBD is in fact legal, the FDA is not actually holding the meetings and comment period on hemp CBD.  Instead, it is “products containing cannabis or cannabis derived compounds”.  By using the word “cannabis” rather than  the 2019 definition of “hemp”, the FDA is taking comment on all cannabis products.  This would show that any testimony or criticism against CBD, would be relating to any “cannabis derived CBD”, not necessarily including legal, hemp derived CBD.

There is certainly lots of other insights to gain from comments and the meeting.  Because of hemp’s popularity, there is a lot more commentary coming out about this, and FDA is open to comments for another three weeks.  Former FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb previously said it could take 3-5 years, so stay tuned for more!!

Ben Droz is contributing editor of Hemp Magazine,  ( available at newsstands and Whole Foods nationwide.  You can also see updates from @TheHempGuy ( or read his blog at . @theHempGuy (Instagram)

Colorado Hemp Company, producer of NoCo Hemp Expo, Southern Hemp Expo, and Let’s Talk Hemp, proudly celebrates 10 Years of Hemp History Week, June 3-9, 2019. (From left: Elizzy Knight, Morris Beegle and Lori Buderus.)
Learn more:

News Briefs

Hemp Takes Wing: TSA Allows CBD on Certain Flights
by Cannabis Business Times

Patagonia Debuts Video About History of Hemp in the U.S.
by Patagonia

Idaho Still Seizing Hemp Shipments, Despite USDA Directive
by Ganjapreneur

Ben & Jerry’s New CBD Ice Cream is in the Works
by Ben & Jerry’s

Headline News

Let’s Talk Hemp’s Morris Beegle Featured in High Times for
Hemp History Week

by High Times

CBD Dietary Supplements Congress Set for Denver, Aug. 15-16
by American Herbal Products Association

CSU Study Finds CBD Beneficial for Epileptic Dogs
by Fox 31 News Denver

World’s Largest Indoor Hemp Greenhouse to Open in Illinois
by NBC 25 News

Square Quietly Launches Credit Card Processing for Cannabis Companies
by Forbes

Ohio Natural Products Retailer Launches Own CBD Brand
by Akron Beacon Journal

Upcoming Events

PCQI and FSMA compliance: why your hemp company needs PCQI training

Let’s Talk Hemp Podcast: On the Road Again

The brand new Episode 25 of the Let’s Talk Hemp Podcast is now available. Recorded live in Knoxville, TN, to celebrate the grand opening of Blühen Botanicals’ new hemp-centric retail store, in this podcast episode “hempreneurs” and hosts Rick Trojan and Morris Beegle share their experiences at the Earthx2019 Expo in Dallas, TX; the Hemp On The Bayou symposium in New Orleans during JazzFest; the grand opening of Blühen Botanicals retail store in Knoxville, TN; and other hemp events around the U.S.A.

Listen Here

Send Us Your Hemp News!
Send press releases and news announcements to

Tree Free Hemp
Herring Bank
Her Many Voices

Become a Subscriber

Get the hemp industry's top newsletter delivered straight to your inbox every Wednesday. 20,000 strong!

Let’s Talk Hemp!

Listen to the hemp industry’s loudest podcast. Produced in conjunction with Loudest Show On Earth Productions. Nothing shall be louder than the truth.

Apple Podcast  Spotify

Earthy Now
Canna Consortium
Make America Hemp Again
Humble Brands


Healthy Oil Seeds
To Top